Kenneth J. Logan, Ph.D., CCC-SLP
Dept. of Communication Sciences and Disorders
1. Write down everything that each speaker says. Before conducting
a speech or language analysis, it is helpful to first transcribe
what your subject has said. It is also quite helpful to transcribe the
speech of your subject’s conversational partner as well. In that
way, you will have a clearer sense of the context within which particular
remarks were made. For the most part, your speech or language analysis
can then be based upon the written transcript and you will not have to
repeatedly return the audio or video tape.
2. Organize the transcript according to utterances. For
our purposes, an utterance will be defined as a string of words or clauses
that (a) communicates an idea, (b) is set apart by pauses, and (c) is bound
by a single intonational contour (Meyers & Freeman, 1985). In many
cases an utterance will simply be a sentence. For example, each of the
two strings of italicized words below would be regarded as an utterance.
Mother: What is that guy called? [One utterance with 5 words in it.]
Child: He is an alien. [One utterance with 4 words in it.]
3. Reference utterances within the transcript. Because you may
want to make reference to specific utterances in your analysis, you should
"identify" each utterance in some way. Because you generally will need
to elicit between 50 and 100 utterances from a child, it is probably best
to reference the child’s utterances separately from the mother’s (or other
partner’s) utterances. Keep your referencing system simple. The most common
way to reference utterances in a transcript is to assign a letter to each
speaker (e.g., M = mother; C = child) and then follow the letter
with number that identifies the particular utterance. For instance,
M1: What is that guy called?
C1: He is an alien.
M2: Oh, I thought he was a soldier.
C2: No, he’s really an alien.
4. Don’t confuse "utterance" with "speaking turn." In the examples
above, both the mother’s and child’s speaking turns consist of only one
utterance. Often, however, a speaker will produce two or more utterances
within a speaking turn. When this happens, put each separate utterance
on it’s own line. For instance,
M1: He’s climbing way up.
C1: He’s probably dizzy.
C2: Let’s pretend that he is dizzy.
C3: I think he needs a doctor.
M2: Who should be the doctor?
5. "Utterance" is not synonymous with "sentence." Although many
utterances in your transcript will be "complete sentences" (i.e., they
will contain a noun and a verb in a subject-predicate relationship), not
all utterances are "complete sentences." In some cases, a speaker will
delete redundant information in his or her speech. The process of deleting
such information is called ellipsis. Consider the following example
(C25) of an elliptical utterance produced by a child:
M25: When do you think he will be ready?
C25: In a little while. [pause]
C26: Hey, let’s get this guy ready too!
In this case, the child’s string of words (In a little while)
does not contain a verb or a subject, yet the string of words is entirely
appropriate in the context. In fact, it would probably seem somewhat stilted
if the child had said, "I think he will be ready in a while." Further,
this particular string of words does meet our criteria for an utterance.
That is, it (a) communicates an idea, (b) is set apart by a pause from
the child’s next utterance, and (c) it is bound by an intonational contour
(i.e., in a while would likely have a falling intonation pattern
associated with it and the following utterance (Hey, ...) would
start out with a different intonational pattern.
6. Utterances should be transcribed verbatim. Speakers often
produce sounds, words and phrases that ultimately have nothing to do with
the final meaning of an utterance. Such vocalizations are called disfluencies.
Consider the following examples:
C34: [This- ]this guy lives over here.
C45: Mom, [can we ]can we go home yet?
C52: [I want-] She’s going to go up in the plane.
C58: [W-w-]we like to see grandpa.
In example C34, the child repeats the word this; in C45, he repeats
the words can we; and in C58, he repeats the consonant [w]. In C52,
the child has apparently "abandoned" his initial attempt at the utterance.
None of the repetitions or abandoned segments add meaning to the sentence,
and so they are regarded as instances of disfluency. Such instances should
be separated from the rest of the sentence with square brackets. While
words, phrases, etc. within the brackets are not typically included in
measures of speech or language complexity (e.g., number of syllables or
words per utterance), it may be interesting to report how many disfluencies
occur within a particular sample.
7. Use standard notation to transcribe speech disfluencies. A carefully developed written transcript can provide a lot of information about a child’s speech fluency. Generally speaking, it is best to use standard notation that captures the child’s disfluent speech behavior. In other words, try to record all instances of sound prolongation, sound or word repetition, revision, etc., in a similar manner. In cases of repetition, try to capture how many times the sound, syllable, or word has been repeated. In cases of prolongation, try to roughly indicate the length of the prolongation but typing either a few (for a brief prolongation) or many (for a long prolonation) characters. Examples are given below.
Utterance Comments
[I, I]You can’t [d-]do that. One revision, one sound repetition.
In some cases, speakers will embed one disfluency within another. In
such cases, bracket all disfluencies together (i.e., as one disfluency)
and make note that several disfluencies are clustered together.
Examples are listed below.
Utterance Comments
[She/he, he, h-he,]you can’t. "she and "he" both subsequently revised,
sound/syll repetitions on "he"
[yyyyou]you can’t go there. Sound prolongation occurs on syllable that
is repeated.
7. "And then, and then, and then": Parsing long sentences. Young
children often rely upon the conjunction and to link together sentences.
In some cases, as many four or five sentences may be linked together at
once. For example,
C61: We went to McDonald’s and we had a Happy Meal.
Beyond the conjunction and, however, all multi-clausal productions
that meet the utterance criteria specified above should be treated as one
clause. For example,
This utterance contains five clauses ((1) the guy should be over
here; (2) who is wearing a hat; (3) but I think; (4) he’s going to stay
with the girl; (5) who has the toy.). Such complex utterances are more
commonly among school-aged children and adults.
9. Selecting a starting point for your transcript. Small children
often take a few minutes to "warm up" when they are being observed. Thus,
the first few minutes of any interaction may consist of numerous one word
utterances (e.g, "Yep," "Nope" and the like). Accordingly, it is generally
wise to start your transcript about 5 or 10 minutes into the audio or video
tape. In this way, you are more likely to end up with a representative
sample of the child’s speech and language abilities.
10. Unintelligible speech: Sometimes the child’s speech will
be hard to understand due to background noise, imprecise articulation on
the part of the child, etc. In such cases, mark unintelligible speech with
a string of two capital X’s (e.g., XX). It is usually possible to hear
how many syllables the child was attempting to say. Thus, if possible try
to mark how may syllables were unintelligible. For example:
Intended utterance: He’s a good baseball player.
What you heard: He’s a good ????????????
Transcribe: He’s a good XX XX XX XX
Although unintelligible utterances should be included in your transcript,
do not attempt analyze the grammatical, semantic, pragmatic, or speech
fluency properties of such utterances. If the unintelligibility stems from
the child’s speech or language skills (and not from background noise),
you may choose to report statistics such as "the number of utterances containing
unintelligible speech" or "the percent of unintelligible syllables" in
your final report. Such measures give additional clues to the examiner
about the child’s speech and language development.
11. Errors in articulation/phonology. Young children do
not always pronounce all attempted words in an adult-like manner. Although
information about the child’s phonology is certainly important, it is not
generally necessary to include such information in your transcript. Instead,
write down the adult gloss of child’s attempted word. For example,
Child says: He "cwimbed" way up the "twee" (child substitutes /w/ for /l, r/)
Child says: He has two car. (Child deletes plural /s/ ending)
Your transcribe: He has two car. (sic)
Child says: She swimming in the pool. (Child deletes auxiliary verb is)
Your transcribe: She swimming in the pool. (sic)
It is advisable to follow such grammatical, morphological, and lexical
errors with the Latin expression sic. In doing so, you tell the
reader that the omitted or incorrect word on the transcript was produced
by the speaker – and not by the typist. Notation such as this is invaluable
in cases when you might be analyzing a transcript over the course of several
days and can’t recall exactly what the child said.